Palestinian rights group accuses Israel of ‘mafia methods’ as U.N. hearings open

Members of the UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry (Eduardo Munoz - Reuters)

Emma Farge

Reuters  /  November 7, 2022

GENEVA – A Palestinian human rights group told a U.N. panel on Monday it had been subject to threats and “mafia methods” during a campaign of harassment organized by Israel to silence groups documenting alleged Israeli rights violations.

Israel dismissed the process overseen by the panel as a sham while it declined comment on the specific allegations.

The independent Commission of Inquiry, established by the Human Rights Council, the U.N. top human rights body, last year, plans five days of hearings which it says will be impartial and examine the allegations of both Israelis and Palestinians.

In the opening session, the commission heard from representatives of Palestinian organizations shuttered by Israel in August and designated as “terrorist” entities.

Shawan Jabarin, General Director of human rights group Al-Haq, denied the terrorism charge and called the closure an “arbitrary decision”, saying Israeli security forces had used “mafia methods” against it in a years-long harassment campaign.

“They used all means, I can say. They used financial means; they used a smear campaign; they used threats,” he said, saying his office was sealed with a metal door on August 18.

Asked to detail the threats mentioned to the panel, Jabarin told Reuters after the hearing that he had received a phone call from somebody he identified as being from “Shabak” [Shin Bet], or the Israel Security Agency, two days after the raid. They threatened him with detention, interrogation or “other means” if he continued his work, he added.

A spokesperson for Israel’s diplomatic mission in Geneva declined to comment on the specific testimony. A spokesperson for Israel’s foreign ministry declined to comment.

“This (COI) and the convening of these sham trials shame and undermine the Human Rights Council,” it said in an earlier statement, saying the commission had an “anti-Israel” agenda.

A U.N. human rights office has previously dismissed allegations of bias and said Israel had not cooperated with the commission’s work.

The first set of hearings will next turn to the killing of the Palestinian-American reporter Shireen Abu Akleh in May.

The U.N. rights office has said its findings suggest that she was killed by Israeli forces while an Israeli investigation concluded she was likely unintentionally shot by an Israeli soldier.

Neither the hearings nor the U.N. Human Rights Council have any legal powers. But investigations launched by the council are sometimes used as evidence before national or international courts.

Israel’s ally the United States has criticized the U.N. Human Rights Council for what it has described as a “chronic bias” against Israel. It quit the body over this in 2018 and only fully rejoined this year.

The three-member COI was created after the 11-day conflict in May, 2021, during which 250 Gaza Palestinians and 13 people in Israel died. The inquiry mandate includes alleged human rights abuses before and after that and seeks to investigate the root causes of the tensions.

Additional reporting by Emily Rose in Jerusalem, editing by Ed Osmond and Tomasz Janowski