Israel’s Ben-Gvir hails ‘sacred’ demolition of Palestinian homes in Negev

MEE Staff

Middle East Eye  /  August 30, 2023

Far-right minister taunts Palestinian citizens of Israel while their homes are being demolished.

Israel’s National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir and Housing Minister Yitzhak Goldknopf cheered on the demolition of houses in a Palestinian Bedouin village, as they oversaw the operation on Tuesday.  

Ben-Gvir praised Israeli authorities for their “sacred work” in demolishing the homes belonging to Palestinian citizens of Israel that the government says were built without permits in the Negev (Naqab) desert.

“Keep it up. It’s important. I also know that this is Minister Goldknopf’s position, to restore deterrence, restore sanity, and restore governance,” the far-right minister said during the demolition 

“Governance starts here, and they will understand that we govern here, that there are the landlords in this country,” he was quoted by Haaretz as saying to a village resident who shouted at him. 

Ben-Gvir later took to Twitter, recently renamed X, to write, “‘Sorry Mohammad Magadli, this is a right-wing government.”

The comment refers to a TV interview he gave last week where Ben-Gvir told news presenter Magadli, a Palestinian citizen of Israel, that his rights were “more important” than those of Palestinians. 

“My right, and my wife’s and my children’s right to get around on the roads in Judea and Samaria, is more important than the right to movement for Arabs [Palestinians],” said Ben-Gvir, using Jewish nationalist terms for the West Bank. 

“Sorry Mohammad,” Ben-Gvir went on to tell Magadli, “but that’s the reality. That’s the truth. My right to life comes before their right to movement.”

The US State Department denounced Ben-Gvir’s “inflammatory” remarks, adding that it condemned “all racist rhetoric”.

Ben Gvir’s triumphalist attendance alongside Goldknopf to oversee Palestinian families being made homeless has sparked an outcry. 

“This tweet demonstrates that the rule of law in Israel has become political,” noted one Twitter user.

In a joint statement with Ben-Gvir, Goldknopf said he had instructed authorities “to act without compromises and concessions, to eradicate the phenomenon and to act decisively against the land thieves.”

Ahmad Tibi, an MP and Palestinian citizen of Israel, called the actions of both ministers “embarrassing”.

‘Judaization’ of the Negev

The Negev is home to some 51 Palestinian villages that the Israeli state does not recognize and regularly targets with demolition. 

The region in southern Israel has been a focus of successive Israeli governments as they seek to dilute the Palestinian presence by building more Jewish settlements. 

In July, an Israeli court gave Palestinian families in the Negev until March of next year to destroy their own homes and leave their village of Ras Jrabah to make way for the expansion of a nearby Israeli city. 

The decision will affect 500 native people from Ras Jrabah.

Residents of the village, which predates the establishment of the state of Israel in 1948, told Middle East Eye that the news fell on them like a “thunderbolt” and was difficult to process.

The Ras Jrabah case began in 2019 when the Israel Land Authority filed 10 eviction lawsuits against 127 residents of the village and their families.

The government body argued that the presence of Ras Jrabah – which is unrecognized as an official village by the state – hindered the expansion of the nearby city of Dimona.

Dimona was built on land owned by the indigenous Palestinian tribe of al-Hawashleh, which also owns land in the adjacent Ras Jrabah.

While residents have said they will protest against the decision and fight it all the way in the courts, they have little faith in the current ultranationalist government, which has placed the acceleration of the “Judaization” of the Naqab at the heart of its guiding policy. 


Far-right Israel ministers attend demolition of Palestinian homes in Negev/Naqab

Middle East Monitor  /  August 30, 2023

Israeli National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir and Housing Minister Yitzhak Goldknopf yesterday attended the demolition of Palestinian homes in Negev/Naqab.

In a joint statement, they stated that they had gone to watch residential buildings ”built illegally in Bedouin villages in the Negev being destroyed.”

Ben-Gvir congratulated the forces destroying the homes for their “holy work.”

The extremist ministers said in their statement that “the people who built the structures were given over three months to vacate the area and destroy the buildings before the state acted to demolish them.”

In February, Israel’s Land Authority carried out the ‘Southern Hawk’ operation, issuing over 360 demolition and evacuation orders.

“Keep it up. It’s important. I also know that this is minister Goldknopf’s position, to restore deterrence, restore sanity and restore governance,” the Jerusalem Post reported Ben-Gvir saying.

He added: “I will continue accompanying the demolitions. I was there a week ago, I am still here today. I will continue to follow and come until the invaders realize that the owner of this country is here.”

Taking to X, formerly Twitter, Ben-Gvir apologized sarcastically to the Palestinian family who are now homeless: “”Sorry” Muhammad Majadla, this is a right-wing government.”

Goldknopf added: “In the first working meeting with the Israel Land Authority, I instructed them to act without compromises and concessions, to eradicate the phenomenon and to act decisively against the land thieves.”

The Negev/ Naqab desert is home to some 51 “unrecognized” Palestinian villages and is constantly targeted for demolition ahead of plans to Judaize the area by building homes for new Jewish communities. Israeli bulldozers, which Bedouins are charged for, have demolished everything, from the trees to the water tanks, but Bedouin residents have tried to rebuild every time.

Bedouin in the Negev must abide by the same laws as Jewish Israeli citizens. They pay taxes but do not enjoy the same rights and services as Jews in Israel and the state has repeatedly refused to connect the towns to the national grid, water supplies and other vital amenities.